I had a great lunch today with a fun past client. He's THE inspiration for the Stat Pack (because he asked questions I couldn't answer when he sold his home. I was hell-bent not to replicate that!). He's a thinker and he asks questions. Lots of questions.
We spoke at some length about a town neither of us had been to, but fascinates us both: Austin, TX.
I'm a Colorado guy, I like small, cool streams, long hikes in the quiet woods, the San Miguel River is right there with the best of Kaua'i for my favorite places I've ever been to. And yet Texas ends up in the equation. Why?
- It seems kind of recession proof
- Inclusive
- Not exclusive
- Good public schools
- Great public higher education
- R&D everywhere and a spirit that embraces that
- Venture Capital
- Not huge, the right size
- Some good recreation
- Good culture
- Good food
- Close to the rest of America
- Not Houston
For me, it's a fascinating place because despite all the oil money that floods into UT and keeps tuition lower than most other mega-universities, the wind and solar power movement in the United States has the biggest following "deep in the heart of Texas".
Why talk about Austin on a Colorado Springs Real Estate Blog?
There is a lot to be said for being recession-proof. There is a lot to be said for massive industrial diversification, for embracing creative and green industries and operating out of the heart first and the wallet second.
The Colorado Springs Real Estate market is still mired in the trough of the market downturn. Nancy Rusinak was quoted in the Gazette today saying "we'll take flat" which is where we are. Why we're flat and not rebounding is because all of the following happened in succession:
- Our supply went up (2003)
- Our demand went up (2003)
- Our prices went up (2004)
- Our demand went up (2005)
- Our supply went up (2005)
- Our demand went down (2006)
- Our supply went way up (2006)
- Our prices went sideways (2007)
- Our supply went up (2007)
- Our prices went down (2007)
- Our supply went sideways (2007 and 2008)
- Our demand showed up... but didn't doing anything (Now)
There is no question that people now want to buy real estate in Colorado Springs.
The problems are:
- They didn't save much during the boom
- Lenders now require this pesky thing called cash in your account
- If they are in tech, they are back to worrying if their job will be here in six months
- If they aren't here, there is no one looking at their home for sale elsewhere
If you do the complicated math and look back in time, our estimates are that two in three buyers last June were relocating to the area. Relo was hot because people from other markets saw their markets starting to tank and liked what they saw here (affordability). They got out before the door hit them on their backsides and they could buy here. Now we're estimating that this June, two in three buyers were local. It's a stretch, but let's do the math: 2/3rds of 1050 sales is about 700 relocating buyers, June 2007 (average relo, down local); 2/3rds of 870 sales is about 570 local buyers, June 2008 (down relo, average local). Total of the two "averages": 1270 units.
There have been only three 1300 unit months ever in our MLS and 1270 would be the 5th best month in terms of unit sales.
If...
Pipe Dream... Over.
What is going on instead is that there is this big give and take that is tearing things up. Buyers here that are local have the desire, but lots of options. They don't ever have their showing interrupted by another eager-beaver buyer hopping out of their agent's Escalade to snipe the property. They know the areas, and often hold out as long as they like for "it". So 1270 units is 100% hypothetical. The present reality is that there is 50% more selection than the 2005 peak and 40% less demand. In showing terms, 1 + 1 does not equal 2, and that delta really means that showings are about 1/4 of the pace they were in 2005. We are seeing 0.8 showings per property right now. Since the buyers are almost all local, there are whole areas of town that don't get shown (because our relocation traffic tends to buy east and if they stay, migrate west).
So here is something you won't find in the Mid-Year Stat Pack: Where Ben predicts the monster deals will be in the next six months. Why "monster deals?" Because sellers are giving up. They are scared. They need to move somewhere, change jobs, or their ARM is about to eat them alive and they've had two years worth of knowledge to know buyers are frugal pesky varmints and their market is entirely composed of frugal pesky varmints so they'll have to deal with them eventually. Ladies and gentlemen, behold the best time to be a frugal, pesky varmint. Understand also, that when I say monster deals, what I'm saying is that presently the active inventory in these areas is still over-priced and will correct to "market value". I think market value looks a lot like what homes were worth (without puff and fluff) in later 2005 and early 2006.
- Flying Horse: Put a big bullseye on this area. There are two kinds of owners in Flying Horse: the ones who bought for the community and Discovery Canyon who don't plan on moving anyway, and the greedy health & wealth, over-leveraged investors/ wannabe-investors. The former is almost completely absent from the roles of present sellers right now, because they bought for the right reasons (the long-term) and filled with dozens of the fly-by-nighters who lived big and cratered bigger. Flying Horse has a lot of smart people living there enjoying the view and the pool and a lot of people who bought a home with a loan designed by a really smart-scheming person, and now they have a bank who can choose to live in their home. Look for more smart people to join the club, especially with the Parade headquartered here in August
- Broadmoor Spires: lots of inventory, not much activity, a huge price appreciation in 2004, 2005, 2006 and even 2007 has left this market slightly over-valued by the selling community. Here the motivation is different, sellers in 80906 tend to have big equity positions. They can almost always get deals done if they need to and they always understand: money is made on the buy. The deals done here could be to go after really big properties further up the hill in the Resort. Ben's favorite stat to date: 13 deals done over $1 million YTD, all of the Pikes Peak MLS. That's it. Again, Broadmoor residents are no dummies. If they want to live larger, they have a great chance.
- All of N/W. The only markets that are selling well right now are under $250,000 in N/E, EAS and PWR. If these are individuals staying in Colorado Springs, they are headed to one of three MLS areas: NGT (see Flying Horse), BRI (Pine Creek, which is number 4) and N/W, almost all of these for D20. Migration patterns are east to west for local buyers and first time home buyers and the limited relo is buying out east. That gives these individuals the opportunity to position their home as a strong value amidst an easy-to-compare marketplace and seek life in the foothills.
- Pine Creek: Big inventory, lots of $475,000 to $650,000 properties heavily impacted by 8% jumbo loans (loans over $417,000). Some major league price wars will happen here this summer and fall, sure to be the talk of the neighborhood. Activity was off the charts in late 2005 and 2006 up here and correspondingly, lots of buyers paid too much in the panicked-buying. Now the harder part comes, the panicked-selling. This will probably be the scene of some fast activity, and while it will probably draw prices down in the next six months, it will be temporary. Pine Creek's location, views, composition and perceived livability by relos and locals alike will allow it to rebound quickly by the start of Summer, 2009.
There are other areas that will probably see some additional activity. Areas that need to see activity include Fountain, especially District 8 and downtown where values have remained relatively stable. There is an abundance of affordably priced, Grade A newer construction for investment purposes. Soldiers will want to live in a house, but they will not want to buy. Rental rates cashflow down here with as little as 10% down.
Am I buying?
Nope. I'm eliminating debt. I'm paying off my car by the end of next month and then I have to get my HELOC worked off. This is also a weak year, I work 100% on commission and I have to have my reserves over-stocked. A buyer should use their real cash not their borrowed cash to act. I'm classifying myself as a 6 to 9 month planner. The money I save from my debt service will allow me to make at least one purchase in 2009.
If I had it would I? Yes on investments. I would 100% buy my own listing on Dassel Drive. But since I'm sitting this year out, I'm part of the "problem".
Recent Comments